Costello's Pizza Emporium

InfoInfo MapMap
1120 Fairport Rd, Fairport, NY 14450 [Directions]
Sunday-Monday: 4:00PM-10:00PM
Tuesday-Thursday: 11:00AM-10:00PM
Friday: 11:00AM-Midnight
Saturday: 4:00PM-11:00PM
585 586 5300
Menu (as of September 2011)
[WWW]7-31-2009 Rochester NY Pizza Blog review

Costello's Pizza and Grill/Costello's Pizza Emporium is a local pizzeria located in Perinton (Fairport address). It is family owned and operated. Features include Friday night beer-battered haddock fish fry and Saturday night All-You-Can-Eat special of salad, pasta, pizza, and chicken wings.


Note: You must be logged in to add comments

2010-07-31 22:53:06   When one of my dad's friends heard we'd moved to Fairport (from Buffalo), he mentioned that he used to work here and highly recommended it. While my parents were up visiting, we stopped by for the "saturday night special." It's basically an all you can eat without a buffet, so your pizza, wings, spaghetti, salads are all made fresh to order.

The restaurant is kind of hidden from Fairport road, in a small plaza tucked behind Abbott's (yes, the plaza contains Abbott's and Costello's ). You can also access it from Baird Rd across from the Fairport Hots parking lot. Walking in, it looks like a standard pizza place: a little lobby with a counter, a menu overhead, kitchen behind it. To the right is a cozy little dining room, probably about 10 tables.

Our waitress was very friendly, and offered us to eat from the menu or to try the special. It seemed that everyone was taking up the awesome deal of the special, as I didn't see anything else at the other tables. Since everything was made to order, it took a little bit to get the food (not instant like a pre-made buffet). We all left stuffed and satisfied. Naturally, you're not allowed to take anything home, so the excess gets junked, so be conservative with your ordering. For four of us, it cost $52 before tip. Not bad considering the amount we ate. —Ackj

2012-06-07 22:32:51   I liked it here. It was a very humble setting, the food was great and the price was right. I typically wouldn't recommend an all-you-can-eat special but it's actually a very good deal here for the quality of food you get. —BatGuano