This page is for comments prior to 2008 for Hicks and McCarthy.
2006-11-13 22:17:50 I went for the first time in September and have been back 4 times. One visit some of the entrees were overcooked but it was better the last time my wife and I went. The Lemon Artichoke soup is fantastic. A good place to go to hear a conversation with people at your table. Some Saturday nights they have live music. —ScottHendler
2007-03-23 07:56:49 Service leaves ALOT to be desired here. Went with a party of 4 most recently and we were abandoned by our server. Took about 20 mins from the time she said she would bring our check, until we actually got it. Food is just ok. —KimBee
2007-07-10 15:07:31 I've only been for breakfast, but the food is good. The service is lacking, but in their defense, they've been super busy every time I've eaten there. Be warned though, the last time I went I had my credit card number stolen by a staff member who was "double swiping" cards and then selling the numbers!!! —RocGirl
2007-07-20 12:30:27 I have never been disappointed here. The salads are great, the entrees are well prepared, the soups are fantastic. —ElaineRobinson
2007-08-04 18:28:29 Back in March of this year, my mother and I attended high tea. Just last week, my bank alerted me to several fraudulent transactions that had been made with my debit card numbers. The bank was able to trace the compromise back to Hicks and McCarthy. So, RocGirl, you're not alone! It happened to me, too. —HeidiWinfield
2007-08-30 11:11:06 This is Pittsfords version of a diner, this is not upscale.
The prices are VERY cheap and the food is good. The servers are all St John Fisher and Nazareth students who mostly do a good job. It is a great place for breakfast or brunch on a Saturday or Sunday in a pleasant atmosphere. —MrRochester
2007-09-20 17:21:03 I have been in email contact with the owner, Robert Bryant, who stated he was unaware I'd called them before to make them aware of this situation. I returned his email & informed him he is welcome to post a comment here about the concerns noted by people in the notes above. Informed him we will not remove their comments —PeteB
2007-11-10 18:33:43 My Mom has been a patron here for years; it was one of her favorite places. With relatives in town, we were a party of 9 in Sep. 07. Had a very surly waitress. My mother ordered the meatloaf. It came in a sauce that she found spicy. She asked for a different entree. The waitress was rude to my Mom and said that she and the rest of the staff don't find it spicy. Wish she knew how much my mother spent there over the past decade! I don't think any of us will be going back. —AmyLa
