I Scream



Former Location
1683 Mount Hope Avenue, Rochester NY, 14620
(Mount Hope Plaza)
CLOSED by the Department of Health on June 12, 2008 until further notice

See Gone, But Not Forgotten.


Note: You must be logged in to add comments

2006-06-15 13:42:32   Excellent for that homemade hot fudge, also homemade strawberry sauce and select ice cream flavors. And a great neighborhood feel —AprilleRoelle

2007-03-31 19:29:38   We go here all the time after Mass at Saint Anne's. It is the best, and the proprietor is a real ice cream enthusiast. —OutSider

2007-06-12 20:39:08   Justin is a great guy who makes incredible fudge. You should go and try it. —EjVanlanen

2007-08-17 12:48:32   This place is like something out of a 50's movie. The decor is totally old school ice cream parlor, the prices are good (especially when he does that "old days" pricing), sundaes are so good, and the owner is really fun to chat with while he makes up your order. We discovered I Scream by accident and now I refuse to go to Abbott's or Friendly's. —KatrinaFromRochester

2007-08-18 11:05:20   He has an insane selection of milkshakes. Where else can you get a strawberry cheesecake milkshake? —CraigCeremuga

2007-08-18 13:32:21   Insanely good ice cream to be found here. The prices are reasonable for the quality of the ice cream. The only thing is, you can only pay for it with cash. No credit cards allowed. —EugeniaHuang

2007-09-13 17:40:35   I Scream does excellent homemade and fresh ice cream. As mentioned, the owner is extremely friendly and helpful (and knows his product, since he makes most of it himself). One drawback is the limited selection available, since it's freshly made. You get quality, but sacrifice variety. —JonPetruccelli

2008-04-18 11:05:15   Wow. Just took a bike ride with some friends and we ended at I Scream. I had the pure Madagascar Vanilla custard with dark chocolate mint below it. It took us 10 minutes just to decide what to get - it all sounds so amazing! 30 milkshake flavors...better get yourself a frequent buyers card. —WillChesebro

2008-09-03 01:55:43   It is a shame...Justin is a great guy too. It seems like it was always more of a hobby than a full time job for him though...hence the inadequate upkeep. —WillChesebro

2008-12-14 15:21:02   So if I Scream had a mouse problem are we to assume that none of the other restaurants / stores in that plaza have the same problem? I won't take any chances so Mt. Hope Plaza is off limits, at least for me. —BatGuano