Recent Changes for "NPOV/Talk" - Rochester Wiki

NPOV/Talk

DaveMahon — 2007-08-14T04:02:45Z

Comment added.

Differences for NPOV/Talk

Deletions are marked with - .	Additions are marked with +.
Line 26:	Line 26:
	+ ------ + ''2007-08-14 00:02:45'' [[nbsp]] You know what? If the wording is a little jarring, that's actually a good thing, because it forces the reader to pay attention. They'll read the rest of the article critically and hopefully figure out how to fix it. --["DaveMahon"]

NPOV/Talk

eastsidestephen — 2007-08-14T03:52:46Z

Comment added.

Differences for NPOV/Talk

Deletions are marked with - .	Additions are marked with +.
Line 24:	Line 24:
	+ ------ + ''2007-08-13 23:52:46'' [[nbsp]] I think that one's a little confusing. Keeping "neutral" or "NPOV" with a link in the description is probably a good idea --["EastSideStephen"]

NPOV/Talk

DaveMahon — 2007-08-14T03:51:47Z

tweaked my comment

Differences for NPOV/Talk

Deletions are marked with - .	Additions are marked with +.
Line 21:	Line 21:
- ''2007-08-13 23:27:53'' [[nbsp]] I'm glad to know that I wasn't the only one not quite happy with my wording. I fully agree with you Stephen, but it's HARD trying to make this succinct and flexible. Hmmm...	+ ''2007-08-13 23:27:53'' [[nbsp]] I'm glad to know that I wasn't the only one not quite happy with my wording. I fully agree with you Stephen, but it's HARD trying to make this succinct and flexible and accurate. It needs to make it clear that including text about the pretty/garish wallpaper is probably acceptable, but ''it's the sux0rs'' is not. Hmmm...
Line 23:	Line 23:
- "This article includes ["NPOV/Definition" strong opinions] and may need revised. Click the "Edit" icon to make changes." --["DaveMahon"]	+ "This article may include ["NPOV/Definition" strong opinions] that may need revised. Click the "Edit" icon above to help!" --["DaveMahon"]

NPOV/Talk

DaveMahon — 2007-08-14T03:27:53Z

Comment added.

Differences for NPOV/Talk

Deletions are marked with - .	Additions are marked with +.
Line 20:	Line 20:
	+ ------ + ''2007-08-13 23:27:53'' [[nbsp]] I'm glad to know that I wasn't the only one not quite happy with my wording. I fully agree with you Stephen, but it's HARD trying to make this succinct and flexible. Hmmm... + + "This article includes ["NPOV/Definition" strong opinions] and may need revised. Click the "Edit" icon to make changes." --["DaveMahon"]

NPOV/Talk

eastsidestephen — 2007-08-14T02:02:55Z

Comment added.

Differences for NPOV/Talk

Deletions are marked with - .	Additions are marked with +.
Line 18:	Line 18:
	+ ------ + ''2007-08-13 22:02:55'' [[nbsp]] More accurate, but less succinct. I think we can do better. --["EastSideStephen"]

NPOV/Talk

rottenchester — 2007-08-14T01:59:23Z

edited comment

Differences for NPOV/Talk

Deletions are marked with - .	Additions are marked with +.
Line 13:	Line 13:
- ''2007-08-13 21:57:36'' [[nbsp]] I think the right way to say it is "This article is the subject of a dispute" but that still doesn't sound too good.	+ ''2007-08-13 21:57:36'' [[nbsp]] I like this addition, too.
Line 15:	Line 15:
- How about "The community isn't sure this article is written from a ["NPOV/Definition" Neutral Point of View]. If you think you can improve it, click the "Edit" icon above"	+ I think the right way to say it is "This article is the subject of a dispute" but that still doesn't sound too good.
Line 17:	Line 17:
- - - I like this addition, too. --["RottenChester"]	+ How about "The community isn't sure this article is written from a ["NPOV/Definition" Neutral Point of View]. If you can improve it, click the "Edit" icon above." --["RottenChester"]

NPOV/Talk

rottenchester — 2007-08-14T01:57:36Z

Comment added.

Differences for NPOV/Talk

Deletions are marked with - .	Additions are marked with +.
Line 12:	Line 12:
	+ ------ + ''2007-08-13 21:57:36'' [[nbsp]] I think the right way to say it is "This article is the subject of a dispute" but that still doesn't sound too good. + + How about "The community isn't sure this article is written from a ["NPOV/Definition" Neutral Point of View]. If you think you can improve it, click the "Edit" icon above" + + + + I like this addition, too. --["RottenChester"]

NPOV/Talk

eastsidestephen — 2007-08-14T01:31:01Z

Comment added.

Differences for NPOV/Talk

Deletions are marked with - .	Additions are marked with +.
Line 10:	Line 10:
	+ ------ + ''2007-08-13 21:31:01'' [[nbsp]] BTW, I don't love my phrasing either. It's taken directly from Wikipedia's NPOV tag, but it sounds a bit awkward to me. Can "disputed" be an adjective? Do we have any grammar experts who can verify the correctness of the phrasing, or possibly fix it if it's wrong? --["EastSideStephen"]

NPOV/Talk

eastsidestephen — 2007-08-14T01:27:43Z

removed odd CR

Differences for NPOV/Talk

Deletions are marked with - .	Additions are marked with +.
Line 9:	Line 9:
- We have had a lot of discussions regarding how we, as a community, should define NPOV. We have generally agreed there is a little room for some non-controversial opinion and conventional wisdom alongside actual facts. - --["EastSideStephen"]	+ We have had a lot of discussions regarding how we, as a community, should define NPOV. We have generally agreed there is a little room for some non-controversial opinion and conventional wisdom alongside actual facts. --["EastSideStephen"]

NPOV/Talk

eastsidestephen — 2007-08-14T01:27:07Z

Comment added.

Differences for NPOV/Talk

Deletions are marked with - .	Additions are marked with +.
Line 7:	Line 7:
	+ ------ + ''2007-08-13 21:27:07'' [[nbsp]] Nice addition Dave. I think this tag will be useful. I changed the phrasing because NPOV is not always black-and-white, so it may be tough to definitively say an article is biased. + We have had a lot of discussions regarding how we, as a community, should define NPOV. We have generally agreed there is a little room for some non-controversial opinion and conventional wisdom alongside actual facts. + --["EastSideStephen"]

NPOV/Talk

eastsidestephen — 2007-08-14T01:13:45Z

Differences for NPOV/Talk

Deletions are marked with - .	Additions are marked with +.
Line 1:	Line 1:
	+ ["NPOV" Parent Page] + + == Talk Page== + This page is where differences in opinions about RocWiki pages are resolved, and notes are left from one contributor to another related to content. + + [[Comments(Talk about the parent page:)]]