Otto Tomotto's

Location

6385 State Route 96, Victor, NY 14564

Hours

Tuesday - Thursday: 11:30AM to 9:00PM

Friday: 11:30AM to 10:00PM

Saturday: 4:00PM to 10:00PM

Sunday: 4:00PM to 9:00PM

Phone

585 742 2070

Accessible

Yes

Alcohol

Info Needed

Website

http://www.ottotomottos.com

Facebook

Reviews

2012-02-02 Rochester NY Pizza Blog review

06-16-2010 Metromix

Otto Tomotto's is an Italian restaurant in the Phoenix Mills Plaza in Victor. It opened in 2004. They also offer catering.

They also own Route 96 BBQ.

Comments:

Note: You must be logged in to add comments

2011-03-28 12:56:31   My husband and I love this restaurant. The food is delicious and the menu is quite broad for an Italian place. I love the crab cake appetizer and the stuffed pork chop entree. Highly recommend! —Bluehen

2012-01-06 14:37:05   Their "tomotto sauce" is the best red sauce I've had in town. It has a nice subtle sweetness and gives the impression that they are using San Marzano tomatoes. They start with bread and a garlic butter spread. It was tasty, but we had enough sense to save a few slices for leftover sauce. We started with French Onion soup and were not that impressed (it was kind of boring and I wouldn't get it again). I got the lasagna and my fiancee got the Greens and Beans and Gnocchi. The gnocchi was good, swimming in the greens & beans & sauce flavored with a nice amount of garlic. The serving portion was enormous and we definitely had leftovers for home. The lasagna was very good and was also a VERY generous portion; I was able to share. The lasagna was drenched in their wonderful sauce and we enjoyed sopping up the remaining pool with the bread. To end the meal, we tried the Trifecta of Fried Twinkies - 3 deep fried small loaves of Italian bread, tossed in cinnamon and sugar, filled with one of their fillings (classic/vanilla, strawberry, and chocolate). They were fantastic, and a perfect end to a very good meal. We are looking forward to our next visit - I think we will try their Stuffed Pork Chop and Chicken Under a Brick. With a side of "tomotto sauce" of course! —MerCDotes

2012-02-13 09:40:34   My boyfriend and I took our mothers here for dinner on Friday night. I made a reservation earlier in the day which is recommended considering how busy they get. We were seated right away by Mama Tomotto. The service was prompt and friendly. I ordered the pork chop special, the others picked lasagna, buffalo chicken pasta and the parm duo (veal and chicken). My pork chop was pan seared and served with roasted veggies, figs and a balsamic drizzle. It was heaven! The buffalo chicken pasta was also delish (I stole a few bites and wanted more!). The lasagna and the chicken also got good reviews. The only complaint was that the veal was a little dry. For dessert we got the trifecta of the fried twinkies: vanilla, chocolate and the special of the day which was cookie dough. The clear winners were the vanilla and the chocolate. Everyone agreed that the cook dough was disappointing. Throughout the course of the meal Mama T checked on us several times which was nice. Overall, I love this place! My mother lives out in Spencerport and stated that she would drive all the way out in Victor to eat here! A+ —dmarie

2013-09-21 21:52:01   Wife & I went tonight-first time. She had Gnocchi's-I had Lasagna. Both outstanding. Very unique, good sauce-obviously made on site. Dessert was Deep Fried Tubers (IE Twinkies)-amazing. Staff are attentive but not overly so. Plenty of parking. Glad we had reservations because walk-ins after us had an hour wait. We'll definitely be back!

One issue not totally their responsibility (moreso the plaza owners): While parking was plentiful, we did not see one Handicapped Designated Parking spot.—peteb

2015-11-19 14:41:48   I used to like this place when they first opened, but the last two times I went it was pretty disappointing. I ordered chicken parmesan the last two times, and I am convinced it is not made to order. The first time I ordered it, where the two pieces of chicken breast overlapped, it was cold!! That tells me they are preparing it ahead of time, and simply reheating it. The menu claims "all homemade", which I feel is a stretch...based on my findings! The last time my clue was the breading..which seemed kind of "meely", like it was prepared in the past, to be reheated in the future. I really want to like this place, but I simply won't be going back. I mean, how difficult can it be for a competent kitchen staff to pound out a chicken breast, cook it in a pan, cover it with fresh sauce and cheese, and pop it in the oven for a few?? I also have noticed lately that the crowd seems to be on the older side, which I guess makes sense given the quality they seem to have slipped to. I hate to do this, but I just wanted people to know about my experiences...perhaps someone else has had similar, or maybe I can save someone else from experiencing what I have. What a shame!

—Bolin