The Cellar Door

Former Location
1 E Church St, Fairport, NY 14450

See Gone, But Not Forgotten

Closed January 2014.


Note: You must be logged in to add comments

2011-05-14 16:59:12   Went here on Saturday for lunch and to check out the Green Lantern for a wedding. I was impressed by the menu, there's a nice selection of items including whiskey from the Finger Lakes Distillery. I had the Cuban sandwich. It was good. I think they cooked it at a bit too high a heat since the cheese didn't really melt, but they did get the bread done right. Service didn't notice my drinks being empty. —DamianKumor

2011-05-14 18:42:44   Went on Saturday for lunch. It's a very small restaurant but the decor is a nice mixture of Victorian and modern (with a peacock theme). The staff and presentation of the food were very good. I had the open faced steak sandwich. The homemade steak sauce is very strong and was not to my liking but it came on the side so it can be avoided. Overall, it was okay. —RachelRobbins

2011-05-17 04:15:27   Had dinner here the other night and really enjoyed it. I'm a vegetarian and I came with my carnivore friend. Was pleased that they had a few veggie options beyond the 'plate of steamed side dishes' that you sometimes find at local eateries. I had the crostini app and the mushroom crepes. Both were delicious. My friend had the haddock and enjoyed his as well. Service was friendly. Seriously good cocktail and beverage selection. Looking forward to trying their lunch menu... —Katemc39

2011-06-18 11:27:43   Went here last night with my husband and we tried lots of small plates. We loved each one! We had the stuffed salt potatoes, homemade pretzels, mini crabcakes and cheese plate. As someone originally from Maryland, I can attest that the crabcakes are top-notch. Looking forward to trying it for lunch! —KatyHanson

2011-11-20 11:27:34   Visited on 11/19/11 for dinner. Excellent concept - LOVE the basement bistro vibe! The menu is creative and still accessible as are specialty cocktails. They also feature a nice selection of local beer as well as Finger Lakes wine and spirits. The downside: Service is adequate at best, friendly but not well-versed in the menu and poorly responsive to details such as refilling water, etc. I hope they work out the kinks! —HonorO'Malley

2012-05-25 15:27:33   Their Black Friday sandwich is so yummy. —TippingPoint

2014-06-03 19:54:00   Closed by January 2014 - GBNF? —jgerek