Recent Changes for "thecityofrochester/Talk" - Rochester Wiki

thecityofrochester/Talk

GaryPalmerJr — 2007-01-29T11:47:45Z

deleted repeat; fixed thought

Differences for thecityofrochester/Talk

Deletions are marked with - .	Additions are marked with +.
Line 25:	Line 25:
- ------ - ''2007-01-28 14:01:30'' [[nbsp]] I am looking for the half-way point, I am not here to cause trouble, I am just attempting to do something good for my website and Rochester. Thanks. --["GaryPalmerJr"]
Line 57:	Line 55:
- ''2007-01-28 19:25:10'' [[nbsp]] Whatever. --["GaryPalmerJr"]	+ ''2007-01-28 19:25:10'' [[nbsp]] RottenChester is right, the original post shouldn't have sounded like an ad; content has to be factual and neutral. --["GaryPalmerJr"]

thecityofrochester/Talk

StevenDibelius — 2007-01-29T05:40:25Z

Revert to version 24 (Not appropriate to edit other people's comments.).

Differences for thecityofrochester/Talk

Deletions are marked with - .	Additions are marked with +.
Line 26:	Line 26:
	+ ''2007-01-28 14:01:30'' [[nbsp]] I am looking for the half-way point, I am not here to cause trouble, I am just attempting to do something good for my website and Rochester. Thanks. --["GaryPalmerJr"] + ------
Line 39:	Line 41:
	+ + Here's the text of the ten links: + + IRS Free Online Filing! + Rosetta Stone + Concert Tickets + Sports Tickets + Tickets & Offers! + Letters From Santa Claus! + Post Your Resume + Order Boxes Online! + Identity Theft Prevention + Start a Freelance Career! +
Line 41:	Line 57:
- ''2007-01-28 19:25:10'' [[nbsp]] RottenChester is right, the original post shouldn't have sounded like an ad; content has to be factual and neutral. --["GaryPalmerJr"]	+ ''2007-01-28 19:25:10'' [[nbsp]] Whatever. --["GaryPalmerJr"]

thecityofrochester/Talk

GaryPalmerJr — 2007-01-29T04:55:07Z

deleted repeat comment; error

Differences for thecityofrochester/Talk

Deletions are marked with - .	Additions are marked with +.
Line 26:	Line 26:
- ''2007-01-28 14:01:30'' [[nbsp]] I am looking for the half-way point, I am not here to cause trouble, I am just attempting to do something good for my website and Rochester. Thanks. --["GaryPalmerJr"] - ------
Line 41:	Line 39:
- - Here's the text of the ten links: - - IRS Free Online Filing! - Rosetta Stone - Concert Tickets - Sports Tickets - Tickets & Offers! - Letters From Santa Claus! - Post Your Resume - Order Boxes Online! - Identity Theft Prevention - Start a Freelance Career! -
Line 57:	Line 41:
- ''2007-01-28 19:25:10'' [[nbsp]] Whatever. --["GaryPalmerJr"]	+ ''2007-01-28 19:25:10'' [[nbsp]] RottenChester is right, the original post shouldn't have sounded like an ad; content has to be factual and neutral. --["GaryPalmerJr"]

thecityofrochester/Talk

adamdewitz — 2007-01-29T00:38:16Z

Comment added.

Differences for thecityofrochester/Talk

Deletions are marked with - .	Additions are marked with +.
Line 58:	Line 58:
	+ ------ + ''2007-01-28 19:38:16'' [[nbsp]] Gary simplified r18. He seems to be OK with the current article text. Lets move on. --["AdamDewitz"]

thecityofrochester/Talk

GaryPalmerJr — 2007-01-29T00:25:10Z

Comment added.

Differences for thecityofrochester/Talk

Deletions are marked with - .	Additions are marked with +.
Line 56:	Line 56:
	+ ------ + ''2007-01-28 19:25:10'' [[nbsp]] Whatever. --["GaryPalmerJr"]

thecityofrochester/Talk

rottenchester — 2007-01-29T00:22:50Z

A "jerk" responds.

Differences for thecityofrochester/Talk

Deletions are marked with - .	Additions are marked with +.
Line 38:	Line 38:
- ''2007-01-28 19:17:35'' [[nbsp]] Gary, your claims are about a web site which is publicly accessible. I fail to see how 10 advertising links to --["RottenChester"]	+ ''2007-01-28 19:17:35'' [[nbsp]] Gary, your claims are about a web site which is publicly accessible. Everyone outside your business can simply navigate to the site and assess the truth of your marketing pitch. So, though you claim that your site's goal is to show the beauty of Rochester, and to show what there is to see and do in Rochester, you have content like that listed below on your site. Hence, the term "specious". + + Also, while we're on the subject of community, there are 3,000 pages in this wiki and you're one of the first to abuse the hospitality offered here by trying to use it as your personal advertising agency, and then call others names when they object to that. + + Here's the text of the ten links: + + IRS Free Online Filing! + Rosetta Stone + Concert Tickets + Sports Tickets + Tickets & Offers! + Letters From Santa Claus! + Post Your Resume + Order Boxes Online! + Identity Theft Prevention + Start a Freelance Career! + + --["RottenChester"]

thecityofrochester/Talk

rottenchester — 2007-01-29T00:17:35Z

Comment added.

Differences for thecityofrochester/Talk

Deletions are marked with - .	Additions are marked with +.
Line 37:	Line 37:
	+ ------ + ''2007-01-28 19:17:35'' [[nbsp]] Gary, your claims are about a web site which is publicly accessible. I fail to see how 10 advertising links to --["RottenChester"]

thecityofrochester/Talk

GaryPalmerJr — 2007-01-29T00:10:35Z

Comment added.

Differences for thecityofrochester/Talk

Deletions are marked with - .	Additions are marked with +.
Line 35:	Line 35:
	+ ------ + ''2007-01-28 19:10:35'' [[nbsp]] RottenChester, you can't count and you seem like a real Rochester jerk. My claims are not specious, but there is no way for anyone outside my business to know that. My original post shouldn't have sounded like an ad and should have been more neutral, still, I think there was not the need for RottenChester to become so vile. There is nothing like that one guy that represents the entire village. I love the sense of community and support we have for each other and our communities. Whatever. --["GaryPalmerJr"]

thecityofrochester/Talk

rottenchester — 2007-01-28T23:28:08Z

Comment added.

Differences for thecityofrochester/Talk

Deletions are marked with - .	Additions are marked with +.
Line 33:	Line 33:
	+ ------ + ''2007-01-28 18:28:08'' [[nbsp]] Gary, would you rather have a neutral entry that doesn't pimp your site, or would you like what's there now, which refutes each of the specious claims you make? You choose. --["RottenChester"]

thecityofrochester/Talk

eastsidestephen — 2007-01-28T19:17:13Z

Comment added.

Differences for thecityofrochester/Talk

Deletions are marked with - .	Additions are marked with +.
Line 31:	Line 31:
	+ ------ + ''2007-01-28 14:17:13'' [[nbsp]] I agree that business owners should not be editing their own pages. I can see owners putting in a comment, as long as they make it clear who they are. Perhaps it could be a stated policy that business owners should not edit their descriptions. A topic for the next wiki meeting maybe? --["EastSideStephen"]

thecityofrochester/Talk

GaryPalmerJr — 2007-01-28T19:12:50Z

Comment added.

Differences for thecityofrochester/Talk

Deletions are marked with - .	Additions are marked with +.
Line 29:	Line 29:
	+ ------ + ''2007-01-28 14:12:50'' [[nbsp]] We have the Current Weather & 7-day forecast up and running, pulling data from NOAA onto TheCityofRochester.com. We have ALL the data for every other service we claim; we are only lacking the programmers to properly scope and complete the projects. We are going to excite people about Rochester. We will be giving ALL info on ALL movies in Rochester, reliable weather, and the ability to chat and have email under TheCityofRochester.com. It is going to be real cool. We are always looking for anyone who would like to help. --["GaryPalmerJr"]

thecityofrochester/Talk

rottenchester — 2007-01-28T19:05:16Z

Comment added.

Differences for thecityofrochester/Talk

Deletions are marked with - .	Additions are marked with +.
Line 27:	Line 27:
	+ ------ + ''2007-01-28 14:05:16'' [[nbsp]] It's still dishonest. The goal of the site is to sell advertising. --["RottenChester"]

thecityofrochester/Talk

GaryPalmerJr — 2007-01-28T19:01:30Z

Comment added.

Differences for thecityofrochester/Talk

Deletions are marked with - .	Additions are marked with +.
Line 25:	Line 25:
	+ ------ + ''2007-01-28 14:01:30'' [[nbsp]] I am looking for the half-way point, I am not here to cause trouble, I am just attempting to do something good for my website and Rochester. Thanks. --["GaryPalmerJr"]

thecityofrochester/Talk

GaryPalmerJr — 2007-01-28T18:59:00Z

Comment added.

Differences for thecityofrochester/Talk

Deletions are marked with - .	Additions are marked with +.
Line 23:	Line 23:
	+ ------ + ''2007-01-28 13:59:00'' [[nbsp]] I am looking for the half-way point, I am not here to cause trouble, I am just attempting to do something good for my website and Rochester. Thanks. --["GaryPalmerJr"]

thecityofrochester/Talk

rottenchester — 2007-01-28T18:56:56Z

More reasons for reversion to a NPOV version.

Differences for thecityofrochester/Talk

Deletions are marked with - .	Additions are marked with +.
Line 20:	Line 20:
- ''2007-01-28 12:43:56'' [[nbsp]] The page reads like a bad marketing pitch and needs clean-up. One suggestion: don't make an article for your own product or Web site. If the community believes your site/products bear the merit they deserve, the community will make those pages. By having the community write the page, the article is more likely to maintain a NPOV.	+ ''2007-01-28 12:43:56'' [[nbsp]] The page reads like a bad marketing pitch and needs clean-up. One suggestion: don't make an article for your own product or Web site. If the community believes your site/products bear the merit they deserve, the community will make those pages. By having the community write the page, the article is more likely to maintain a NPOV. -- ["AdamDewitz"]
Line 22:	Line 22:
- ''2007-01-28 13:45:35'' [[nbsp]] There are almost 3,000 pages in this wiki. Three of them have generated controversy: The D&C page, the Robert Duffy page, and this one. In the other two examples, the wiki community has decided that --["RottenChester"]	+ ''2007-01-28 13:45:35'' [[nbsp]] There are almost 3,000 pages in this wiki. Three of them have generated real controversy: The D&C page, the Robert Duffy page, and this one. In the other two examples, the wiki community has decided that we value sticking to the facts and representing both sides of a controversy, if one exists. Unlike the D&C and Bob Duffy, there is no controversy over thecityofrochester.com, and the facts are pretty clear-cut. The claim that it is a "community resource" is false on its face. There are a few paragraphs about Rochester and a few links to Rochester-related sites, but the top third of every page is a clickable advertising map. It is an advertising site, not a community resource. The other claims made in the page are also false. It is not a "community meeting place" - there are no interactive features in the site. It is not an "excellent source of information" - there is more advertising than information. --["RottenChester"]

thecityofrochester/Talk

rottenchester — 2007-01-28T18:45:35Z

Comment added.

Differences for thecityofrochester/Talk

Deletions are marked with - .	Additions are marked with +.
Line 21:	Line 21:
	+ ------ + ''2007-01-28 13:45:35'' [[nbsp]] There are almost 3,000 pages in this wiki. Three of them have generated controversy: The D&C page, the Robert Duffy page, and this one. In the other two examples, the wiki community has decided that --["RottenChester"]

thecityofrochester/Talk

adamdewitz — 2007-01-28T17:43:55Z

Comment

Differences for thecityofrochester/Talk

Deletions are marked with - .	Additions are marked with +.
Line 19:	Line 19:
	+ ------ + ''2007-01-28 12:43:56'' [[nbsp]] The page reads like a bad marketing pitch and needs clean-up. One suggestion: don't make an article for your own product or Web site. If the community believes your site/products bear the merit they deserve, the community will make those pages. By having the community write the page, the article is more likely to maintain a NPOV.

thecityofrochester/Talk

GaryPalmerJr — 2007-01-28T16:11:22Z

Comment added.

Differences for thecityofrochester/Talk

Deletions are marked with - .	Additions are marked with +.
Line 17:	Line 17:
	+ ------ + ''2007-01-28 11:11:22'' [[nbsp]] RottenChester, TheCityofRochester.com is a community resource website for Rochester. Yes, the features I mentioned are not yet running, and you are right, RocWiki needs to be factual and neutral, but TheCityofRochester.com is not just another MDH pixel site. There is a soul, and there are very real goals to this website. I would appreciate if we can not water its meaning down, keep it real, neutral, and factual. I hope this last edit will meet your satisfaction. --["GaryPalmerJr"]

thecityofrochester/Talk

rottenchester — 2007-01-28T15:33:15Z

Gary - please read before editing.

Differences for thecityofrochester/Talk

Deletions are marked with - .	Additions are marked with +.
Line 16:	Line 16:
- ''2007-01-28 10:27:20'' [[nbsp]] Gary, this is not a forum to advertise your site. Your site consists of a couple of links about rochester along with some ads. --["RottenChester"]	+ ''2007-01-28 10:27:20'' [[nbsp]] Gary, this is not a place to make inflated claims about your site. Your site consists of a couple of links about Rochester along with some ads. Most of the features that you've mentioned (movies, chat, email) are not implemented. The calendar is stale - it has a few events from November, 2006. We want to keep our entries factual and neutral. Your last edits are neither. --["RottenChester"]

thecityofrochester/Talk

rottenchester — 2007-01-28T15:27:20Z

Comment added.

Differences for thecityofrochester/Talk

Deletions are marked with - .	Additions are marked with +.
Line 15:	Line 15:
	+ ------ + ''2007-01-28 10:27:20'' [[nbsp]] Gary, this is not a forum to advertise your site. Your site consists of a couple of links about rochester along with some ads. --["RottenChester"]

thecityofrochester/Talk

adamdewitz — 2006-12-27T04:52:17Z

Comment added.

Differences for thecityofrochester/Talk

Deletions are marked with - .	Additions are marked with +.
Line 13:	Line 13:
	+ ------ + ''2006-12-26 23:52:17'' [[nbsp]] After Rotten's NPOV edit, I think the page is OK to keep. --["AdamDewitz"]

thecityofrochester/Talk

eastsidestephen — 2006-12-26T14:46:54Z

Comment added.

Differences for thecityofrochester/Talk

Deletions are marked with - .	Additions are marked with +.
Line 11:	Line 11:
	+ ------ + ''2006-12-26 09:46:54'' [[nbsp]] Looks good to me --["EastSideStephen"]

thecityofrochester/Talk

rottenchester — 2006-12-25T15:49:54Z

Comment added.

Differences for thecityofrochester/Talk

Deletions are marked with - .	Additions are marked with +.
Line 9:	Line 9:
	+ ------ + ''2006-12-25 10:49:54'' [[nbsp]] Well, see what you think. --["RottenChester"]

thecityofrochester/Talk

eastsidestephen — 2006-12-25T03:55:50Z

Differences for thecityofrochester/Talk

Deletions are marked with - .	Additions are marked with +.
Line 1:	Line 1:
- [thecityofrochester]	+ ["thecityofrochester"]

thecityofrochester/Talk

eastsidestephen — 2006-12-25T03:55:20Z

fixed link to parent

Differences for thecityofrochester/Talk

Deletions are marked with - .	Additions are marked with +.
Line 1:	Line 1:
- Link to Parent Page Here	+ [thecityofrochester]
Line 8:	Line 8:
- ''2006-12-24 22:53:26'' [[nbsp]] This looks like an advertisement. Should it be deleted? Modified? --["EastSideStephen"]	+ ''2006-12-24 22:53:26'' [[nbsp]] The parent looks like an advertisement. Should it be deleted? Modified? --["EastSideStephen"]

thecityofrochester/Talk

eastsidestephen — 2006-12-25T03:53:26Z

Comment added.

Differences for thecityofrochester/Talk

Deletions are marked with - .	Additions are marked with +.
Line 7:	Line 7:
	+ ------ + ''2006-12-24 22:53:26'' [[nbsp]] This looks like an advertisement. Should it be deleted? Modified? --["EastSideStephen"]

thecityofrochester/Talk

eastsidestephen — 2006-12-25T03:52:45Z

Is the parent page appropriate?

Differences for thecityofrochester/Talk

Deletions are marked with - .	Additions are marked with +.
Line 1:	Line 1:
	+ Link to Parent Page Here + + == Talk Page== + This page is where differences in opinions about RocWiki pages are resolved, and notes are left from one contributor to another related to content. + + [[Comments(Talk about the parent page:)]]