Jeremiah's Tavern, Monroe Ave 3-2008

Jeremiah's Tavern is a Bar/pub with noted chicken wings and 20 beers on tap. They have a full menu, going well beyond typical bar food. The dining room is child friendly.

Awards

Jeremiah's was voted 'Best Fish Fry' in City Newspaper's 'Best Of' Awards for 2008.¹

Also, they often win D&C's "Best of Rochester" award for best wings.

Free Wifi

Comments:

Note: You must be logged in to add comments

---

2006-01-25 19:27:54   Great food and lots of fun to hang out at. Best Buffalo wings in the authentic style. —LindaMarie

---

2006-01-26 23:16:14   Child friendly, yes, but only until 9 PM. I'm 20 and they wouldn't let me in to the dining room on a Tuesday night at 9:15, even though it's separated from the bar. —RachelBlumenthal

---

2006-09-14 10:37:07   Great food, great atmosphere, would definetly go back there again. I had the chicken pesto sandwich and loved it. The wings are VASTY overrated, no different than hot wing's I've had at a hundred other locations. If you want wings to remember, try Dinosaur Bar-B-Que or Buffalo Wild Wings Grill & Bar. —TravisOwens

---

2006-09-14 11:57:49   With regards to my last comment, now I'm 21 and I'm not bitter anymore :) Anyway, the French dip is great, as are the wings, although you should order them a step up on the spicy scale. What they call "hot" tastes more medium, "medium" tastes mild, etc. —RachelBlumenthal

---

2007-01-06 21:30:53   One of the better burgers in Rochester, and the wings are quite good. One of the groups I'm involved in usually comes here after our meetings on Wednesday and I usually look forward to it. —RufoSanchez

---

2007-02-26 18:42:56   Lousy service. Rude wait staff. An hour to wait for wings, a salad and potato skins is considered normal?? The wings were cold and tasted lousy. I can't understand why this restaurant keeps getting rave reviews. Not worth the very long wait:( —JoanneTeacher

---

2007-03-23 08:35:26   I love Jeremiahs. Good food, nice servers. They always have a good selection of yummy soups. —KimBee

---

2007-04-21 09:16:38   I second the soup comment - I've never been disappointed in Jeremiah's soups. I enjoy myself more when we mange to get a booth in the back room rather than a table in the louder front section. Be mindful that the menu changes based on day of week and time. For example you can't get wings at dinner on Fridays until after a certain hour (9pm or 10pm I believe). —EllenKelsey

---

2007-10-21 09:11:18   I haven't been there in a while, but they did have one of the BEST Fish Frys I've ever had. Need to get back there soon! —MarkStrickland

---

2008-01-05 20:39:34   I've actually been to eat here quite a few times, usually ordered a burger and a beer and it was decent. We went to eat on this past Friday night and they had a much fancier menu, no burgers on it, although I overheard the waitress tell someone else they could still order it. We had a $50 gift card and we had an appetizer, a pitcher of beer and two main entrees. It still wasn't $50! Not too shabby. I got the 10oz steak, with mashed potatoes on the side. It was cooked exactly to medium rare, but slightly less flavorful than a cut at an upscale steak house. The mashed potatoes were garlic and very tasty. My boyfriend got a stuffed parm chicken, with rice, and it was impressive looking. He really enjoyed it. We split mozz sticks (perfect) and there was also bread on the table. Besides being quite loud, it was a great and fairly cheap date! —SaraChristine

---

2008-03-26 15:36:59   Pretty much live there... been there so many times I can't even count. Never had a horrible experience & the wings are one of the best in town. Plus, they have Rohrbach's Scotch Ale on tap which is a beautiful thing! —TriciaSeymour

---

2008-04-05 12:22:14   Possibly our visit a few weeks back for a Friday fish fry was an anomaly for Jeremiah's always seems to get great reviews. Since moving from the neighborhood I hadn't been in for a few years. My dining companions and I were surprisingly and sorely disappointed with our food and experience. Our beer-battered fish was over-fried and oozing grease (the fries and slaw were OK, nothing great). On top of this we were rushed through our meal by the waitstaff so as to turn over the table. Probably won't be back for a fish fry any time soon. —LizDee

---

2008-04-07 02:16:28   The chicken wings I had at Jeremiah's tonight were pitifully small. Too bad, I used to enjoy the wings here. —NathanHenderson

---

2008-04-24 14:09:09   Jeremiahs has some of the best wings and pub grub in the area.

The inside is the typical dive bar, but dont let that turn you away, the wings are excellent. —SteveVogt

---

2008-06-02 01:24:54   I really think the wings here are SEVERELY OVERRATED. Every time I get them (standard hot wings) they're soggy, cold, have no depth of flavor, and are barely spicy. I want a semi-crispy buffalo wing with bold flavor and these simply aren't up to par. The wings at MacGregor's are way, way better in every possible way. —MariahBetz

---

2008-07-31 16:50:33   Great place for affordable bar food. Their burgers and sandwiches are all very good, especially their French dip and Lori's Sizzler. I agree with others about the wings being overrated, though. I've had better wings at a number of other places in town. —JohnHavard

---

2008-09-19 15:11:16   This bar really depends on what time of day and what day of the week you go. At night, its generally filled with meatheads and skanks. Their beer and liquor selection is adequate, though their drinks tend to be overpriced and weak. The bartenders are solid and great to talk to when the place is quieter. The food is typical bar food, I've never been impressed but I've never really been let down either. Its something to put in my stomach when I'm drunk. Overall mediocre, so if I didn't own a house within walking distance I would pretty much never go here. —MarcusKroll