Main Street Bar & Grill

Former Location
120 East Main Street, Rochester NY, 14604
CLOSED (as of October 2009)

See Gone, But Not Forgotten.

Is now Legends Sports Bar & Grille.


Note: You must be logged in to add comments

2007-02-02 11:18:26   This location is no longer a Bennigan's. It's now called Main Street Bar & Grill. —RachelBlumenthal

2008-02-28 12:02:54   I do not recommend this restaurant. I cannot explain how awful of a dinner experience I had here. They only accept 1 credit card per table, so unless our part of 6 all sat at separate tables we could not pay for our meals separately. Second, a majority of their dinner menu consisted of steak, which they were out of. Our meal took around 40 minutes to arrive (appetizer with the meals). I'm going to continue this on another comment because there's more and it won't let me post more than 1000 characters. —JenniferLis

2008-02-28 12:15:14   Continued... The excuse was that they were busy and only had 1 cook on, yet there was one other party in the dining area and 2 people at the bar. My salad came out 5-10 minutes after everyone's meal. Our orders were missing sides or had the wrong sides. Most of us got garlic mashed potatoes which were absolutely vile. They tasted as if they were scraped off the floor and had rotting garlic in them. 2 of my friends got the salmon which was simply a dry piece of fish, no seasoning, no lemon, nothing. Most of my party didn't even end up eating their meals. We asked to speak with a manager but they never showed up, we were communicating our complaints through the waiter and host. We waited after for the check, which never came and we couldn't find anyone to ask for it. Finally we put on our jackets and stood around hoping someone would get it for us. Only 1 meal was knocked off the bill. Again needing to continue… —JenniferLis

2008-02-28 12:15:30   Continued Part 3… Many other things went wrong including the tiny menu with very expensive prices, a claim that there was no orange soda yet we could see it in the soda fountain and it was put on our bill as "Orange". We even went as far as walking over and filling the cup ourselves to see if it gone….it wasn't.
Who knows, maybe lunch is better. —JenniferLis

2009-11-09 18:11:10   This place is now called Legends. We had a coupon from After being seated, it was about 4-5 minutes before our drink order was taken. The restaurant had probably 5-6 front of house employees from what I could see, and there were only about 3-4 other tables in use, so this was a discouraging wait time. Our appetizer, bacon and cheddar fries, was EXTREMELY disappointing. The bacon all fell to the bottom, the cheese wasn't spread out well, and best of all....all the shredded cheese wasn't even melted. The service and the food improved as the meal progressed. Bottom line, because of it's area its way overpriced, and I wouldn't recommend it unless you had a coupon. —mbetush